Update 3/7/12: If you want to sign an online petition, click here.
Update 3/9/12: The bill has been tabled, the Chicago Tribune reports.
PEORIA -- Here's a post from Karen Hudson, an anti-CAFO activist:
The Illinois legislature is considering an“Ag Whistleblower” bill proposed by Representative Jim Sacia that would make criminals out of people who document illegal practices and pollution at industrial livestock operations.
House Bill 5143, if passed, would make it a crime to record videos, photograph, or even for the media to possess images of these facilities.
It would make felons out of those who document pollution events and reeducate the public about where their food comes from.
Documentation assists Illinois agencies such as IEPA to do their job. This bill is representative of efforts across the country by corporate agribusinesses to shield their unsavory production practices from public scrutiny.
Over a century ago, Upton Sinclair’s The Jungle exposed deplorable practices and conditions at U.S. meatpacking plants. His work led to significant public pressure and ultimately better regulation at processing facilities.
Illinois citizens should be asking themselves why the corporate Ag lobby would go to such measures today to criminalize this type of documentation.
Legislators should be called on to vote against HB 5143 and to demand even greater transparency of routine production practices at industrial animal feeding operations.
In addition, Illinois citizens need to be aware of the new AGRO-Security Group that is comprised of the FBI, the Illinois Farm Bureau, Illinois State police, and animal industry groups such as the Illinois Pork Producers and others.
This “working group” was created to “improve security” around agricultural enterprises in Illinois. While on the surface this MAY LOOK inconspicuous, the group also focuses on prohibiting photos of animal factory operations as they pollute our resources and/or abuse animals.
FBI Agent David Ford said in a recent Associated Press article in the Chicago Tribune that “creating the working group is an attempt to get in front of security issues before something terrible happens.”
The group’s brochure advises farmers to watch for mysterious livestock deaths, unauthorized people taking pictures, and attempts to borrow farm equipment "for no logical reason”, according to the AP article.
The brochure advises agriculture producers to copy license plates of “mysterious people” that will immediately be entered into a national database.
In other words, if you are caught taking photos of a factory farm in violation, you will be entered into an FBI file among other things. This story tells itself. It is another PR stunt to stop the enormous opposition to animal abuses and polluting and factory farms in Illinois.
In 2002 the Chicago Tribune featured editorial titled “Oink if You Smell Bad Legislation.” This was in response to an industry sponsored bill that would ban photos or videotaping at "animal facilities" with intent to "damage the enterprise." If implemented it would have made it a Class 3 Felony to take a photo of an animal feeding operation in Illinois. The Illinois House was duped into passing this due to the fact that it was inconspicuously attached at the very end a seemingly good ”antiterrorism” bill.
Again, Illinoisians smell something rotten with the recent introduction of HB 5143 Illinois Representative Sacia. This bill is industry sponsored attempt to stifle perfectly legal actions that document illegal actions at factory farms.
Some verbage within the bill states that … A person commits animal facility interference when he or she, without the consent of the owner, knowingly: possesses or distributes a record which reproduces by a photographic, audio or similar medium an image or sound of a visual or audio experience occurring at the animal facility.
Any person who commits animal facility interference is guilty of a Class A misdemeanor for a first offense and a Class 4 felony for a second or subsequent offense. Factory farm supporters claim they have a clean slate but know that their egregious growing practices and pollution events can be consistently revealed in photographs that lead to investigations and/or fines. If they have nothing to be ashamed of, why all the coverup?
If you use on facebook you can keep up with ICCAW news at
http://www.facebook.com/pages/The-Illinois-Citizens-for-Clean-Air-and-Water/220119024675170
To SAY NO TO AG GAG BILL HB 5143
The members of the Illinois House Judiciary Committee are listed below. The top five names (in bold) are the individuals most important to contact. Please encourage as many people as possible to call their Springfield offices and email them, stating their opposition to the Ag-Gag bill.
Please circulate these names and numbers and flood these offices with calls. Every call makes a big difference!
Elaine Nekritz - 57th District: (217) 558-1004, enekritz@repnekritz.org lurnikis@hds.ilga.gov
Lou Lang - 16th District: (217) 782-1252, langli@ilga.gov
Sidney H. Mathias - 53rd District: (217) 782-1664, repmathias@hotmail.com
Ann Williams - 11th District: (217) 782-2458, ann@repannwilliams.com
Michael J. Zalewski - 21st District: (217) 782-5280, michaelz@ilga.gov
John E. Bradley - 117th District
Jil Tracy - 93rd District
Michael G. Connelly - 48th District
Dwight Kay - 112th District
Andre Thapedi - 32nd District
Arthur Turner - 9th District
Contact information for the other members on this list can be found at:
http://www.ilga.gov/house/committees/members.asp?CommitteeID=895&GA=97
Here are some of the issues:
1. Documentation is routinely utilized by citizens to record illegal and pollution events.
2. Documentation "tells the story" of AG. The real side producers do not want to reveal. This information will help promote socially responsible agriculture.
3. Illinois EPA cannot be everywhere at once. Citizens in our state shoulder the burden of policing intensive animal feeding operations on a daily basis.
4. Documentations of alleged violations on intensive animal feeding operations and on manure application sites are forwarded to many Illinois agencies and assist tin the enforcement of warnings and penalties.
5. Documentations help to create increased public health awareness of intensive animal feeding operations and the safety and the quality of the food that they produce. This results in consumer protection and food safety initiatives.
6. The routine use of antibiotics to promote growth of diseased or healthy animals promotes antibiotic resistance in the human population. Documentation continues to educate the public about conditions behind closed doors that affect public health.
This is a national movement. Link to other states regarding AG GAG BILLS:
It's a map of states where similar bills like Sacia's in IL are being proposed
http://animalvisuals.org/
From a newspaper article: Ag Gag or CAFO protection passes in Iowa, will be heard in Illinois.
Last week we reported on an Iowa bill aimed at preventing undercover investigations at concentrated animal feeding operations that was on Gov. Terry Brandstad's desk.
At the time Brandstad's office said it was still considering but late Friday he quietly signed it to the dismay of activists who'd hoped to stop it.
"Governor Branstad has failed Iowa, and the American people," said Nathan Runkle the executive director of Chicago-based Mercy for Animals. "By siding with those who seek to keep Iowa’s corrupt factory farming practices hidden from public view and signing this bill into law, he has created a safe haven for animal abuse and other criminal activity in the state. Mercy For Animals, along with a broad coalition of national groups representing a wide spectrum of public interests, including animal welfare, civil liberties, public health, food safety, environmental protection, food justice, workers' rights, and First Amendment interests, is exploring all legal avenues to overturn this dangerous and un-American law."
The bill in Iowa focuses on criminalizing the use of false pretense to gain access to the CAFO and the Governor commented on that aspect of the bill during his weekly press conference today.
"My feeling is if somebody comes onto somebody else's property through fraud or deception or lying, that is a very serious violation of people's rights," Branstad said at his weekly news conference according to the Associated Press. "People should be held accountable for that...this is a reasonable public policy for the state of Iowa. I think a number of states will probably follow us."
Many Illinois sustainability and environmental groups--including the Illinois Coalition for Clean Air and Water, Mercy for Animals and the Humane Society of the U.S.--hope this will not be the case and have pledged to make their voices heard as Illinois holds hearing on its own similarly-aimed Animal Facilities Bill HB5143 on Wednesday. Illinois recently launched an online program where supporters and opponents can file "witness slips" for hearings even if they can't be there and they can be filled out for that bill here.
"This bill will criminalize neighbors of CAFOs from taking photos of environmental violations in their community," said Karen Hudson an Illinois farmer and spokesperson for ICCAW. "We are the EPA's local eyes and ears. The EPA needs photographs to document alleged environmental violations. This ignores public health in our community."
“At the behest of the multibillion-dollar meat, dairy and egg industries, similar Ag-Gag bills are being proposed in states all across the country, including Illinois, New York, Utah, Indiana, Minnesota, Missouri and Nebraska," Runkle noted. "Unfortunately, Iowa’s flawed and misdirected new law could set a dangerous precedent nationwide by throwing shut the doors to industrial factory farms and allowing animal abuse, environmental violations, and food contamination to flourish undetected, unchallenged, and unaddressed."
Runkle noted that undercover investigations have resulted in landmark corporate and public policy changes as well as massive food recalls in the past.
"Without undercover investigations," he said, "there are oftentimes no effective watchdogs protecting animals from egregious cruelty in these facilities or the public from serious health violations."
Karen L. Hudson
Socially Responsible Agricultural Project consultant www.sraproject.org
Illinois Citizens for Clean Air and Water www.iccaw.org
Families Against Rural Messes FARM
farmer
Elmwood, Illinois
309-742-8895
I